Amtrak: When the Train Beats Flying
The US routes where Amtrak is as fast or faster than flying door to door, how fares compare, and when the train makes sense for comfort, cost or scenery.
On a map, flying always looks faster. But once you add getting to the airport, security, boarding and the trip from the arrival airport into the city, a two-and-a-half-hour train ride often wins. Trains also go city center to city center, and you can work, eat and move around the whole way.
Routes where the train usually wins
| Route | Fastest train | Flight time | Why the train wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York–Washington | About 2 hr 45 min (Acela) | About 1 hr 15 min | Penn Station and Union Station are downtown; no security lines |
| New York–Boston | About 3 hr 45 min (Acela) | About 1 hr 20 min | Similar door-to-door time, more space |
| New York–Philadelphia | About 1 hr 10 min | Rarely flown | The train is faster than driving or flying |
| Los Angeles–San Diego | About 2 hr 45 min (Pacific Surfliner) | About 50 min | Coastal views, no traffic, downtown to downtown |
| Seattle–Portland | About 3 hr 30 min (Cascades) | About 55 min | Downtown stations, scenic, cheaper |
| Chicago–Milwaukee | About 1 hr 30 min (Hiawatha) | Rarely flown | Frequent and cheap |
| Chicago–St. Louis | About 4 hr 30 min (Lincoln Service) | About 1 hr 15 min | Comparable door to door, often cheaper |
Times are typical scheduled times. Amtrak's newer NextGen Acela trains, which entered service in 2025, are gradually replacing older Acela sets on the Northeast Corridor.
When flying is better
Long-distance trains are about the experience, not speed. Chicago to Los Angeles takes about two days by train and four hours by plane. Delays on long-distance routes are also common, because Amtrak shares most tracks with freight railroads.
One email a week. The gear worth buying and the fares worth booking.
No affiliate padding. If we wouldn't recommend it to a friend, it doesn't go in.
How fares compare
- Book early. Amtrak uses demand-based pricing, so the cheapest fares sell out first. Saver fares are cheapest but have restrictions.
- Acela costs more than Northeast Regional trains, which take a little longer.
- Discounts: Seniors, kids, students, veterans and military get discounts on many fares.
- No bag fees. Coach passengers can bring two personal items and two carry-ons free, plus checked bags on many routes.
Comfort
Even coach seats have far more legroom than airline economy, and there's Wi-Fi on most trains, though it can be patchy. Business Class adds more space and a free drink on many routes. On long trips, consider a room. See Amtrak sleeper cars, explained.
Tips
- Arrive 30 minutes early at big stations; boarding starts 10 to 20 minutes before departure.
- Use the Amtrak app for tickets and track numbers.
- Sit on the scenic side: east side (left heading south) for the Pacific Surfliner's ocean views between LA and San Diego.
- Bring food. Café cars are pricey.
See also Brightline Florida: a rider's guide.
Sources
- Amtrak: Routes and schedules, checked October 2026
Part of our getting around guide.
What's changed: First published October 19, 2026.


